And the Lighting Winner is:

Option 3 was the clear winner for our voters and for me!

Here's before:

 And here's after!

I love, love, love this light and the ambience it now creates in my dining room!  I got it from Overstock.com and paid $180.  That is a great price.  Davy and I hung it on Saturday (For a lighting tutorial, click here)  I encourage you to look around, find what you want and then buy it online.  You will save a ton of money!