Pirate hats...$14 for 12
Treasure chest boxes...$3.99 for 12
Swords...$10.99 for 12
Telescopes...$2.99 for 12
...and these were my favorite! Pirate finger puppets! They came in a set of 24 for $6. I used them on his cake also for decoration!
A little secret if you live near a Partyland, you can have your items shipped to their store for free! It requires a little planning as it takes about three weeks for items to arrive...but it saves you the $10 they charge to ship! Just write the online item numbers down, take them to the store and they have a form for you to fill out.
Happy party planning!